ARCHETYPAL

Do not base academic or grading decisions solely on AI-detection output.

AIR-1A04293BCD · version 2 · Governance · candidate interpretation

Instructors should-not rely detector output.

Situation & purpose

An AI system or employee activity involves detector output. Confirm the actor and source conditions before using this template.

Provide a traceable control for the action: rely detector output.

Examples

Meets the rule
instructors performs the required action "rely" for detector output within these source conditions: Within the source scope; assess applicability before adoption., and retains evidence.
Does not meet the rule
instructors omits the required action "rely" for detector output while those source conditions apply.
Outside scope
The actor, activity, jurisdiction, or applicability conditions in this source variant do not match.

Evidence & enforcement

  • Dated record of the action
  • Responsible actor and approval, where required
  • Applicable source edition and scope

Human or authorized system adapter required. Machine-executable: no. Convert to a reviewed organization contract and validate the adapter before deployment.

Limits

A rule card is an interpretation aid, not an applicability determination.

Equivalent intent does not make different source obligations interchangeable.

Owner review

Record your interpretation decision. This does not adopt a policy for an organization.

Owner sign-in

JSON rule card
{
  "id": "AIR-1A04293BCD",
  "version": 2,
  "title": "Do not base academic or grading decisions solely on AI-detection output.",
  "text": "Instructors should-not rely detector output.",
  "topic": "Governance",
  "intent": "rely detector output",
  "status": "candidate",
  "semanticStatus": "human-validation-required",
  "variants": [
    {
      "sourceId": "msu-genai-guidelines",
      "control": "Teaching and Learning, detection paragraph",
      "sourceVersion": "Approved August 12, 2025; no revisions listed",
      "url": "https://ai.msu.edu/guidelines",
      "actor": "instructors",
      "modality": "should-not",
      "action": "rely",
      "object": "detector output",
      "condition": "Within the source scope; assess applicability before adoption.",
      "exception": null,
      "timing": null,
      "authority": "organization-specific",
      "jurisdiction": "Michigan State University, US",
      "checkedAt": "2026-09-28",
      "status": "interpretation-needs-review",
      "examples": {
        "meetsRule": "instructors performs the required action \"rely\" for detector output within these source conditions: Within the source scope; assess applicability before adoption., and retains evidence.",
        "doesNotMeetRule": "instructors omits the required action \"rely\" for detector output while those source conditions apply.",
        "outOfScope": "The actor, activity, jurisdiction, or applicability conditions in this source variant do not match."
      }
    }
  ],
  "situation": "An AI system or employee activity involves detector output. Confirm the actor and source conditions before using this template.",
  "purpose": "Provide a traceable control for the action: rely detector output.",
  "examples": {
    "meetsRule": "instructors performs the required action \"rely\" for detector output within these source conditions: Within the source scope; assess applicability before adoption., and retains evidence.",
    "doesNotMeetRule": "instructors omits the required action \"rely\" for detector output while those source conditions apply.",
    "outOfScope": "The actor, activity, jurisdiction, or applicability conditions in this source variant do not match."
  },
  "evidence": [
    "Dated record of the action",
    "Responsible actor and approval, where required",
    "Applicable source edition and scope"
  ],
  "enforcement": {
    "mode": "policy-template",
    "adapter": "Human or authorized system adapter required",
    "machineExecutable": false
  },
  "limitations": [
    "A rule card is an interpretation aid, not an applicability determination.",
    "Equivalent intent does not make different source obligations interchangeable."
  ],
  "createdAt": "2026-10-03",
  "updatedAt": "2026-10-03"
}
Back to registry